Aarrow Ecoburn 5 vs Aarrow Signature 5: Stove Showdown

Two compact stoves, one tough decision. Compare the Aarrow Ecoburn 5 and Signature 5 in our ultimate side-by-side stove showdown.

Two compact stoves. One winner for your hearth.

When it comes to compact stoves, Aarrow offers two strong options that are very similar in size, but worlds apart in style and purpose. The Aarrow Ecoburn 5 and the Aarrow Signature 5 are both steel-bodied stoves with cast-iron doors, rated at 5kW nominal output and designed to slot into fireplace openings or sit happily freestanding.

On paper, they’re nearly identical in footprint and performance. But in reality, they serve two different types of customer — one who values flexibility, the other who leans into clean-lined modernism and the simplicity of wood-only burning. Whether you’re fitting a stove into a traditional chimney breast or starting from scratch in a newly renovated space, one of these stoves likely has your name on it.

Design: Familiar Comfort or Clean-Lined Cool?

Let’s start with design and aesthetics, because while the specs are similar, the style isn’t. The Ecoburn 5 wears its heritage proudly — with gently curved corners, an arched viewing window, and that signature Aarrow look that has become a favourite in UK homes for years. It looks right at home in country cottages, Victorian fireplaces, and more traditional interiors.

The Signature 5, by contrast, is bolder and cleaner. It has straight edges, a wider stance, a minimalist glass-fronted door, and a sleeker silhouette overall. It also features a solid stainless steel door handle, which not only looks the part but offers better grip and durability compared to the Ecoburn’s painted handle. Despite appearances, the two models share near-identical dimensions, so your installation options stay the same — but the vibe they bring to a room couldn’t be more different.

When it comes to fuel handling, the Ecoburn 5 is the more versatile of the two. It’s a multifuel stove, supplied with a fixed grate system that allows you to burn both logs and approved solid fuels like anthracite or smokeless ovals. Beneath the grate sits a removable ashpan, making cleanup quick and painless. For those who live in areas without wood supply or who burn daily for heating, that fuel flexibility is a major advantage.

The Signature 5, however, is a wood-only stove, designed specifically for clean-burning log fires. It uses a flat cast-iron base tray with a couple of small ash slots that let embers fall into a concealed ashpan below — offering some of the tidiness of a multifuel setup, but with the cleaner combustion profile of a dedicated wood burner. While the Signature lacks a riddling grate, its internal geometry is optimised for wood, creating a better ember bed and improving secondary combustion efficiency.

Controls & Combustion: Wood Purist vs Multifuel Flexibility

Both models feature Aarrow’s well-regarded airwash system, helping keep the large front glass panel clearer for longer. The Ecoburn 5 gives you separate sliders for primary and secondary air, letting you tweak the burn manually depending on fuel type. This is especially helpful when switching between coal and wood.

The Signature 5, on the other hand, simplifies things with a single combined air control, which feels more intuitive and responsive for everyday log burning. If you’re the type to micro-manage airflow, the Ecoburn gives you that freedom. If you’d rather set it and forget it, the Signature makes things easier. Both stoves are available in dedicated Smoke Exempt (SE) versions for use in DEFRA-designated smoke control areas, so there’s no need to mess around with kits — just order the right variant for your postcode.

Build quality is solid across the board. Aarrow stoves are made in the UK with strong welds, thick steel plate, and reassuring door weight. The Signature 5 feels slightly chunkier — especially in the door and handle — and the heavier internal base gives it a more solid sound and feel when loading. The Ecoburn’s door is lighter and opens with less resistance, which some may prefer. Internally, the fireboxes are laid out slightly differently.

The Ecoburn 5 has a deeper chamber, better suited to end-on log loading or taller stacks. The Signature is a touch wider, making side-loading easier and improving flame visibility across the broader glass window. Both will comfortably accept logs up to 300mm (12 inches) in length, but if you prefer a theatre-style flame presentation, the Signature edges ahead.

Aarrow Ecoburn 5
Aarrow Signature 5

Check out our Stove Spotlight on the Rocal D7 — a wall-mounted elliptical woodburner that turns up the heat and the style.

Technical Comparison

Feature Aarrow Ecoburn 5 Aarrow Signature 5
Nominal Output 5kW 5kW
Efficiency (Wood) ~79% ~82%
Fuel Type Multifuel Wood only
Smoke Control Compliance Dedicated SE model available Dedicated SE model available
Air Controls Dual sliders Single combined slider
Ashpan Yes Yes (via ash slots)
Grate Yes (fixed) No
External Air Kit Optional Optional
Log Length (Max) 300mm 300mm
Construction Steel body, cast-iron door Steel body, cast-iron door
Handle Black finish Stainless steel
Dimensions (W×H×D) ~430 × 550 × 365mm ~430 × 550 × 365mm
Weight ~75kg ~80kg

Which One Should You Choose?

Choose the Ecoburn 5 Plus if you want:

  • Multifuel capability (wood and smokeless)
  • An ashpan and riddling system for easy maintenance
  • A stove that fits easily into older fireplace openings
  • A classic design with a familiar feel

 

Choose the Signature 5 if you want:

  • A sleek, modern design for open-plan or contemporary spaces
  • Higher efficiency from a wood-only setup
  • Cleaner lines and fewer moving parts
  • Better external air compatibility for low-energy homes

Both the Ecoburn 5 Plus and the Signature 5 are serious contenders. You’re not going to be disappointed either way — but knowing your space, your fuel preference, and how you use your stove day-to-day will help you land on the right model.

This isn’t a question of good vs bad — it’s a matter of best fit. One leans traditional, the other contemporary. One offers flexibility, the other refined focus.

And finally — here’s the part that’s most exciting right now. Both of these stoves are currently available as ex-display units, with limited stock and significant discounts. They’re in excellent condition — fully functional, tested, and supplied with the standard warranty. A few small scuffs or handling marks might be present, but it’s nothing that impacts performance or longevity.

If you’ve been holding out for a compact stove but don’t want to pay full price, this is a rare chance to grab a premium Aarrow stove at a serious saving. Whether you go for the Ecoburn’s versatility or the Signature’s refinement, you’re getting a British-built stove that will serve your home for many winters to come. But with these offers, it’s first come, first burned — so don’t hang about.

Either way, you’re buying British, you’re buying quality, and you’re buying a stove that’s built to last.

About This Spotlight

This Stove Spotlight was originally published on the Fireplace Products blog back in 2014. As part of our acquisition of the Fireplace Products YouTube Channel, we also gained access to these historic posts, which were written by myself and my team. To preserve the archive and maintain continuity with the videos, we’ve re-formatted and re-uploaded them here using their original post dates.

If you’d like to explore our latest reviews and features, you can find all of our most recent Stove Spotlights here.

 

Which would you choose — the classic multifuel Ecoburn 5 or the modern wood-only Signature 5? Leave a comment below and tell us which Aarrow stove earns a place in your home.

See related stories to this one:

Picture of Reece Toscani

Reece Toscani

Reece has over two decades in the fireplace and stove world — testing, reviewing, and occasionally getting covered in soot, all in the name of wood-fired home heating. He cuts through the nonsense, busts the myths, and shares straight-talking advice to help you enjoy your stove without the confusion. From Fireplace Products to Redefining Woodburners, if it burns wood, he’s probably tested it, fixed it, or argued about it. Now, through Woodburner Insights, he shares that experience with the world — both here and on YouTube.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *